Moderating user uploads means nothing goes live until it has been checked, every uploader confirms that the people shown are adults who consented and that they hold the rights, visitors can report problems easily, and reported videos come down fast. If you ever find suspected child sexual abuse material, report it to the proper body, NCMEC in the US or the IWF in the UK, and get legal advice. Uploads are the riskiest part of running a tube site, so build the process before you open uploads to the public.
This guide describes common practice in general terms. Your legal duties depend on where you and your users are. Get advice from a lawyer.
Decide whether to accept uploads at all
Many tube sites work only with content from producers and sponsor feeds, where the source keeps the records and holds the rights. Opening uploads to members brings community content, but also copyright claims, consent issues and the risk of illegal material. If you accept uploads, consider limiting them at first to verified or trusted members.
Use an approval queue
With an approval queue, uploads are encoded but stay private until a moderator approves them. This is the single most important safeguard. A moderator should:
- Watch enough of each video, and check the thumbnails, to be confident about what it shows.
- Reject anything where anyone appears to be under 18, or where age is in doubt.
- Reject anything that suggests lack of consent, hidden filming or intoxication.
- Check that the title, description and tags are accurate and not misleading.
- Check for watermarks or logos suggesting the uploader does not own the content.
Write these rules down so every moderator applies the same standard, and when in doubt, reject.
Uploader attestation
Before uploading, the member should confirm that everyone shown was at least 18, that everyone consented to being filmed and to the video being published, and that the uploader owns the content or has the rights to publish it. An attestation is not proof, but it sets clear rules, shows what you require and supports enforcement when someone breaks them. Some operators go further and require identity and age verification of uploaders and documentation for everyone shown. Discuss with a lawyer what is appropriate for your sites, including in relation to 2257 record-keeping.
Make reporting easy
Every video page should have a visible report option with clear reasons, such as:
- Person appears to be under 18
- Non-consensual or private content
- Copyright infringement
- Other illegal or inappropriate content
Also provide a contact route for people who appear in a video and want it removed, without forcing them to create an account.
Remove content fast
Speed matters. For the most serious report types, the safest approach is to take the video offline straight away and review afterwards, rather than leaving it live while you investigate. Then:
- Review reports at least daily, and more often for serious categories.
- Remove thumbnails, previews and cached copies, including on any CDN.
- Suspend or ban the uploader where appropriate, and review their other uploads.
- Keep a log of reports, decisions and dates.
Copyright reports follow their own process; see handling DMCA takedowns.
Reporting child sexual abuse material
If you come across suspected child sexual abuse material (CSAM), take it offline immediately and report it:
- In the US, report to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) through its CyberTipline. US-based providers have a legal duty to report apparent CSAM they become aware of.
- In the UK, report to the Internet Watch Foundation (IWF). Where a child may be in immediate danger, contact the police.
- Elsewhere, national hotlines exist in many countries, and the INHOPE network lists them.
Do not copy, download, forward or share the material, even to colleagues, as that may itself be an offence. Get legal advice promptly about your obligations, including any duty to preserve information for law enforcement.
Look after your moderators
Moderation can expose people to distressing content. Limit shift lengths, rotate tasks, give moderators a clear way to escalate and access to support, and make sure they never feel pressured to approve doubtful content.
How Tube Site Script helps
Tube Site Script supports member uploads with an approval queue, so nothing appears until it is approved, and uploaders must give an age, consent and rights statement. Visitors can report videos, and reports of underage or non-consensual content take a video offline immediately for review. Each site has page stubs for Terms, Privacy, DMCA and 2257 that you edit with your own policies.
Because the library is shared, an approved video can be shown across your network according to each site's content settings, and you moderate it once. These tools support your process but do not replace it or legal advice. See the tube site software features and pricing.
Frequently asked questions
Should uploads go live immediately?
It is safer to hold uploads in an approval queue until a moderator has checked them, so nothing harmful appears publicly.
What should a moderator do if age is in doubt?
Reject the video. When there is any doubt that everyone shown is an adult who consented, the safe choice is not to publish.
Where do I report suspected CSAM?
In the US, to NCMEC through its CyberTipline. In the UK, to the Internet Watch Foundation, and to the police if a child may be in danger.
